Search Site
Manhattan DA Seeks $22M Restitution from 9/11 PTSD Scammers

More than three years after indicting 137 alleged scammers who falsely claimed 9/11-related PTSD, Manhattan’s District Attorney is still seeking to reclaim $22 million in fraudulent payments. The New York Post reported that several of the accused fraudsters incriminated themselves with audacious social media posts that contradicted their claims of disability. These included:

  • Glen Lieberman — The 19-year veteran of the NYPD, including service with the Brooklyn South Gangs Unit, “falsely claimed to have assisted at Ground Zero on 9-11, was ordered to pay $250,000 in restitution and complete 250 hours of community service after pleading guilty to third-degree grand larceny.” Lieberman had claimed he was so traumatized by 9/11 that he couldn’t leave his home, but a Facebook photo showed him riding a Sea-Doo in Florida.
  • Richard Cosentino — Former NYPD officer Richard Cosentino accepted more than $200,000 in disability payments, but was able enough to land an enormous marlin during a fishing trip to Costa Rica, and proudly posed with his trophy for the camera. According to the Post, in 2015, Cosentino “pleaded guilty to second-degree grand larceny in exchange for a conditional discharge and an order to pay $207,000 in restitution.”
  • Louis Hurtado — The ex-NYPD cop’s case is yet to be heard, but Hurtado apparently worked as a martial arts instructor, advertising his services online, despite “illegally pocketing $470,000 over 26 years — the most money over the longest period of anyone charged.”

On the flip side, the Post reports “four defendants who won dismissal of the charges against them filed $40 million worth of ’malicious prosecution’ suits against [Manhattan DA] Vance earlier this year in Manhattan federal court.” Those lawsuits aside, the DA’s work in this case is vitally important for all 9/11 responders and survivors for two very good reasons.

First, the scammers’ unjust enrichment unjustly deprives legitimate claimants of funds they deserve. But perhaps more importantly, this level of fraud creates a stigma impugning claimants who cite post-traumatic stress disorder as a disabling condition. Such a stigma can prevent PTSD sufferers from getting the benefits and treatment they deserve, thus dooming them to a life with often unbearable symptoms.

As attorneys for 9/11 responders and survivors, we at Barasch & McGarry applaud the DA’s efforts to root out fraud in the disability system. However, we’re also sensitive to the fact that too zealous and sweeping a prosecution can snare innocent claimants, unjustly stigmatizing them and others who are considering a PTSD claim. We hope this sad episode reaches a just conclusion, which may include a fair settlement for wrongly accused defendants.

If you are suffering from PTSD following the attacks of 9/11, contact an experienced Zadroga Act benefits attorney at Barasch & McGarry. We have represented 9/11 survivors from the outset. Call us at 888-351-9421 or contact our office online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Compensation available to residents and office workers, teachers and students – not just responders and volunteers
Our Attorneys
  • "Barasch McGarry Salzman & Penson handled everything professionally and with patience. They always had time to answer all my questions and did what they promised. Thanks esp to Brian Calamaris Lee London, and Mariya Atanasova. Thank you." - William Collins, FDNY

  • "If I could give them six stars I would...don't even bother talking to anyone else concerning 9/11. The whole team worked night and day to deliver an outstanding settlement. They are honest, hard working and extremely professional. Just make the one phone call and let them do the rest." - Les Margulis, resident in the exposure zone

  • "I had a very good experience with Michael and Mariya. They made the process stress free. I would recommend this firm to anyone seeking assistance with 9/11 related illnesses." - JE Kirwan, worked in the exposure zone

  • "The people at this firm were just great. They were concern with making sure I was taken care of in every way possible. When I was given an award Mr. Barasch didn't think it was a fair amount and appealed the decision which got me a larger award. I am very satisfied with everything they did for me in the past and are willing to do for me and my family in the future." - Bob Wiecezak, FDNY-Retired

  • "Excellent law firm. Lee London and his staff were very responsive and always followed up with phone calls or emails. This firm is a strong example of what caring and personable lawyers are all about." - Letitia Egan, wife of client, volunteer in the exposure zone

  • Deadline Extended to Register for Compensation

    There is still time to apply for significant compensation if you have been diagnosed with any of the 68 cancers that doctors at the WTC Health Program (WTCHP) have linked to the WTC toxic dust. The deadline to apply to the Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) is two years from the date that a cancer has been certified by the WTC Health Program — or any other governmental agency. The two-year period to register doesn’t start on the day of a cancer diagnosis. Rather, it starts only when a cancer survivor is made aware their cancer was linked to exposure to the WTC toxins.

    For those who died from their WTC-linked cancers, the two-year period for their family to register starts on the day of the death of the WTC victim.

    Register For Compensation

Please help spread the word about the strict two-year deadline to register a claim

Many people have tried to complete the VCF application on their own, only to learn that it requires answers to hundreds of questions and many documents to download. It would be our pleasure to help you complete the process in order to ensure that you receive the compensation that you are entitled to. Please call us for a free consultation.

Let a knowledgeable attorney help you figure it out

A cancer diagnosis can be terrifying. You undoubtedly have questions about your disease and how you will pay for treatment. Lawyers at Barasch & McGarry ensure you understand the complex requirements and help devise the best strategies for obtaining compensation and appropriate medical care under the Zadroga Act. Contact our law firm online or call 888-351-9421. The initial consultation is free, so it costs you nothing to find out whether a lawyer can help.
  • Barasch & McGarry Personal Injury Websites

  • Subscribe to our Newsletter

  • Contact Us

    Fill out the form below with any questions or info on how to get your free consultation

    Quick Contact Form