Search Site
When Getting Sued Feels Good

Before you get the wrong idea, I’ll admit that getting sued is usually not something to be particularly happy about. As a rule, it’s expensive, stressful, and time consuming. But, believe it or not, there are times when getting sued actually feels kind of good. When the lawsuit affords us the opportunity to take on a company that is exploiting 9/11 victims, it feels better than good.

Mike Barasch and the Barasch McGarry law firm are being sued by a financial lending company, because we refused to release funds to pay the exorbitant interest it is demanding from one of our 9/11 clients. Far from feeling unhappy about it, we are very motivated to take on a company that we believe is preying on the 9/11 community.

We represent Elmer Santiago, a disabled NYC Police Officer who suffered career-ending respiratory injuries as a result of his toxic exposure during the WTC rescue and recovery operations. Forced to retire without any benefits, Officer Santiago had no income for years and he ultimately found himself in a desperate situation. He needed to find housing for his family.


Several years ago, there was an 18-month delay between getting a Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) award determination letter and receipt of the VCF award payment. Officer Santiago decided to use the award letter as collateral to borrow $355,000 from a company called RD Legal Funding. With the money that was lent to him, he bought a modest home in Florida and moved his family to the warmer climate so that he would be able to breathe easier. He believed that he had borrowed the money from a reputable company, and that he would be charged the 19% interest that was in the loan document. Nineteen percent is a substantial amount of interest on what is essentially a risk-free loan. But it is in line with what other lawsuit lending companies charge. However, when Officer Santiago finally received his award payment, he learned, to his utter shock, that the lending company was demanding payment of $855,000 based on a 67% interest rate! In a word. Outrageous.

Appalled, Barasch told RD Legal that its lending agreement with Officer Santiago, and the interest rate it was seeking, had the appearance of violating both NYS and Federal criminal usury laws. Barasch promptly re-paid RD Legal $355,000, the amount that it had lent Officer Santiago. He then told the lending company that if it ,didn’t dramatically reduce its $505,000 demand for interest, he would ask the Department of Justice (which oversees both the Victim Compensation Fund and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau [CFPB]) and the NYS Attorney General’s office to determine the permissible amount of interest.

Both the CFPB and the NYS AG’s office were willing to investigate RD Legal’s lending practices. AG Eric Schneiderman was quoted as saying that the lending company’s practice of giving advances to first responders seeking settlements appeared to amount to a high-interest loan that violated state law. While the practice of giving loans to accident victims who have lawsuits can be risky for a lender, VCF claimants who have received an award letter are entirely different. The key difference between lending to someone in a car accident who brings a lawsuit versus lending to a 9/11 claimant who has a VCF award, is that car accident lawsuits aren’t guaranteed, while VCF awards are guaranteed.


Last week, feeling the heat from both investigations, and from being ordered by the AG’s office to pay back $1.6 million to other 9/11 victims, the lending company sued the Attorney General and the CFPB. The Attorney General called the lawsuit “frivolous” and said RD Legal “exploited and shortchanged 9/11 victims,” according to the Daily News. The company maintains that the advances are “purchases of future settlement money,” not “loans.” It argues that it should be permitted to charge high fees because it takes on “the risk” that a settlement may never be reached. However, both Schneiderman and Barasch pointed out that RD Legal incurred no risk since the VCF awards are guaranteed by the Federal Government.

So, despite being in the middle of a lawsuit, Michael Barasch feels confident that he is doing the right thing. “It’s comforting to know that I’m on the same side of a lawsuit as the Attorney General and the CFPB. While it may be expensive for me to defend this lawsuit, it’s worth it. Officer Santiago was a victim of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. I’m not going to let him be a victim twice,” said Barasch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Compensation available to residents and office workers, teachers and students – not just responders and volunteers
Our Attorneys
  • "Barasch McGarry Salzman & Penson handled everything professionally and with patience. They always had time to answer all my questions and did what they promised. Thanks esp to Brian Calamaris Lee London, and Mariya Atanasova. Thank you." - William Collins, FDNY

  • "If I could give them six stars I would...don't even bother talking to anyone else concerning 9/11. The whole team worked night and day to deliver an outstanding settlement. They are honest, hard working and extremely professional. Just make the one phone call and let them do the rest." - Les Margulis, resident in the exposure zone

  • "I had a very good experience with Michael and Mariya. They made the process stress free. I would recommend this firm to anyone seeking assistance with 9/11 related illnesses." - JE Kirwan, worked in the exposure zone

  • "The people at this firm were just great. They were concern with making sure I was taken care of in every way possible. When I was given an award Mr. Barasch didn't think it was a fair amount and appealed the decision which got me a larger award. I am very satisfied with everything they did for me in the past and are willing to do for me and my family in the future." - Bob Wiecezak, FDNY-Retired

  • "Excellent law firm. Lee London and his staff were very responsive and always followed up with phone calls or emails. This firm is a strong example of what caring and personable lawyers are all about." - Letitia Egan, wife of client, volunteer in the exposure zone

  • Deadline Extended to Register for Compensation

    There is still time to apply for significant compensation if you have been diagnosed with any of the 68 cancers that doctors at the WTC Health Program (WTCHP) have linked to the WTC toxic dust. The deadline to apply to the Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) is two years from the date that a cancer has been certified by the WTC Health Program — or any other governmental agency. The two-year period to register doesn’t start on the day of a cancer diagnosis. Rather, it starts only when a cancer survivor is made aware their cancer was linked to exposure to the WTC toxins.

    For those who died from their WTC-linked cancers, the two-year period for their family to register starts on the day of the death of the WTC victim.

    Register For Compensation

Please help spread the word about the strict two-year deadline to register a claim

Many people have tried to complete the VCF application on their own, only to learn that it requires answers to hundreds of questions and many documents to download. It would be our pleasure to help you complete the process in order to ensure that you receive the compensation that you are entitled to. Please call us for a free consultation.

Let a knowledgeable attorney help you figure it out

A cancer diagnosis can be terrifying. You undoubtedly have questions about your disease and how you will pay for treatment. Lawyers at Barasch & McGarry ensure you understand the complex requirements and help devise the best strategies for obtaining compensation and appropriate medical care under the Zadroga Act. Contact our law firm online or call 888-351-9421. The initial consultation is free, so it costs you nothing to find out whether a lawyer can help.
  • Barasch & McGarry Personal Injury Websites

  • Subscribe to our Newsletter

  • Contact Us

    Fill out the form below with any questions or info on how to get your free consultation

    Quick Contact Form